
When a fire engineer or the NCC calls for steel to achieve an FRL such as 60/-/- or 120/-/-, the steel needs protection that slows how quickly it heats up. In Australia the two most common ways to do that are intumescent paint and vermiculite (cementitious) fire spray. We apply both every week across Sydney and NSW, so here is how they actually compare on site.
How each one works
Intumescent paint is a thin-film coating, usually a few hundred microns to a few millimetres thick. In a fire it swells many times its applied thickness and forms a carbon char that insulates the steel. Day to day it looks like paint and can be top coated in almost any colour.
Vermiculite fire spray is a lightweight cement and vermiculite mix sprayed on much thicker, typically tens of millimetres. It doesn't need to react to work. Its bulk and low conductivity insulate the steel from the start. The finish is textured and grey or off-white, so it suits areas where looks don't matter.
Side by side
| Intumescent paint | Vermiculite fire spray | |
|---|---|---|
| Finish | Smooth, paintable, architectural | Rough, textured, functional |
| Thickness | Thin film (microns to a few mm) | Thick (typically 10–50 mm+) |
| Cost per m² | Higher, rises steeply at FRL 90–120 | Usually lower, especially at higher FRLs |
| Best for | Exposed steel, shopfronts, lobbies, balconies, off-site coating | Carparks, plant rooms, above ceilings, warehouses, ductwork |
| Surface prep | Blasted or prepared steel plus compatible primer | Clean steel, often over primer or mesh as the system requires |
| Durability | Hard film; external use needs the right system and top coat | Can be damaged by impact; best in protected areas |
| Programme | Multiple coats and drying time; can be done off-site | Fast coverage on site; messy, so it needs masking |

What drives the thickness and the price
Neither system has one standard thickness. The required dry film thickness (intumescent) or spray thickness (vermiculite) is read from the manufacturer's assessed data. It depends on:
- The FRL. 120 minutes needs far more material than 60 minutes. With intumescent the jump can be steep.
- The section's exposed surface area to mass ratio (ksm). Light, thin sections heat faster and need more protection than heavy ones. A 150UC30 needs more than a 310UC118 for the same FRL.
- 3-sided or 4-sided exposure. A beam supporting a slab is usually treated as 3-sided.
- Critical steel temperature from the structural engineer, where provided.
- Access, height, masking and site conditions. These matter on small jobs as much as the material does.
As a rule of thumb, small light sections at FRL 90–120 are where vermiculite usually wins on price. Exposed steel at FRL 30–60 is where intumescent is often the sensible choice.
Which one should you choose?
- Steel will be visible (retail, lobbies, residential, external columns): intumescent.
- Steel is hidden or in a back-of-house area (carpark, plant room, above a ceiling): vermiculite, usually at lower cost.
- High FRL on light sections: price both. Vermiculite is often far cheaper.
- Steel is being fabricated and you want it ready to erect: off-site intumescent can save site time.
- Galvanised steel: both are possible, but the system must allow for galvanising and use the correct primer.
We often quote both options side by side so the builder can see the trade-off clearly.
Compliance and sign-off
Whichever system you choose, it must be used within its tested and assessed scope (AS 1530.4 testing, with steel design to AS 4100). It has to be applied at the thickness that scope requires. We record thickness readings, and at handover we issue an installation certificate stating the product, FRL and members treated, ready for your certifier.
Need this priced?
Send your drawings, fire engineering report or a few photos. We'll come back with a fixed quote, the tested system we'd use, and an installation certificate at handover.
